The Nakhl Fort Oasis and the Maison Tropicale

Case Study

An analysis of Jean Prouvé's La Maison Tropicale and the Nakhl Fort and Oasis in Oman discussing relationships in climate responsive design, chains of production, enforced control and relief architecture.



Monday, January 11, 2010

Jean Prouvé



Jean Prouvé (1901-1984)





Jean Prouve in front of the characteristic porthole windows. (Source)



Prouvé was a French modernist, and believed strongly in creating a new world with industrial materials and processes. In particular, he aimed to mass-produce affordable designer objects and homes. He began his career as an iron worker when he was fifteen. He assisted Le Corbusier and other modernist architects through to the late 1920s. In 1924 he opened his very own workshop in the town of Nancy, which he later transformed into a design studio. After five years of furniture design for universities, hospitals, lecture halls, and various other public buildings, he returned to a more engineered architecture. Over the next ten years, his ties with the government deepened as he designed prefabricated barracks for the French army, emergency refugee housings, and even became the mayor of Nancy for a brief time. With an expansion and relocation of his workshop, Prouvé had all the tools required for designing La Maison Tropicale: an extensive technical foundation, experience in designing prefabricated modular buildings, and a strong relationship with the government.



-Clara Walker




Information Citation:


"Jean Prouve: La Masin Tropicale, The House, The Architect, The Exhibition".
http://lamaisontropicale.com/www/
(accessed January 9 1010).



Image Source:


"Prouve" (image). Available from: A Few Items of Interest
http://www.maritimequest.com/warship_directory/france/aircraft_carriers/charles_de_gaulle_r91/fs_charles_de_gaulle_general_de_gaulle.htm

(accessed January 5 2010).

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Constructing a Spaceship

Although the sites for La Maison Tropicale were in Africa, the buildings were actually manufactured in Prouvé's atelier in Paris and then shipped to Naimey, Niger and 3,800 miles to Brazzaville in 6 containers loaded into the belly of an airplane. All of the components were flat and tightly packed yet each container was light enough for 2 men to carry.








House being unloaded from plane



The ability for the Maison Tropicale to be constructed and dismantled easily was critical to its design. Because the primary and most difficult tasks of construction were done at Prouvé's atelier, the jointed steel-frame structure was very easy to put together by the time it got to Brazzaville.







Unloading of the building and beginning of construction in Naimey, Niger.



Prouvé tried to mimick the system of cooling implemented in the Congo's local architecture yet maintain strength against the elements that traditional European construction offered.








Testing of construction in Maxeville, France



The Masion Tropicale's shell was made using a folded sheet-steel frame with both fixed and sliding wall panels. There were two central steel supports, shaped like inverted U's, which were the principal load bearers. These two supports were located in the inner cella portion of the Maison that was surrounded by a veranda on all sides; the incurring load was thus carried by the exterior veranda walls.








Louver detail from reconstruction building (Source)




Many parts of the house were adjustable, such as louvers and sliding doors, allowing for adequate ventilation needed in the Congo's warm and humid climate. These louvers were also designed to reflect the sun and deflect rain from hitting the walls of the building.








Porthole detail (Source)



Blue glass portals on the walls protected from solar radiation entering the interior.






Interior construction of the double-roof and roof venting. (Source)


The house's double roof structure with a long chimney down the center facilitated interior cooling and ensured permanent air circulation. This roof venting was protected by gauze so that mosquitos and other bugs could be kept out of the interior of the Maison.









Wooden slatted floor (Source)





The floor was made of wooden slats, also allowing for further ventilation from the cool air below the building, and was built upon metal pillars to raise the structure.









La Maison Tropicale was wired for electricity and included plumbing (Source)











Video of La Maison Tropicale being assembled at Tate Modern
http://www.wallpaper.com/art/la-maison-tropicale-jean-prouve/2084

-Tegan Maccari



Information Citations:


Henry, Patrice. Jean Prouve: La Masin Tropicale, The Tropical House. Paris: Editions du Centre Pompidou, 2009.



"Jean Prouve: La Masin Tropicale, The House, The Architect, The Exhibition".
http://lamaisontropicale.com/www/
(accessed January 9 1010).

Peters, Nils.
Prouve. Hohenzollernring: Taschen, 2006.


Image Sources:


"Installation view of the tropical house involved in an expirement at Maxeville" (image). Henry, Patrice. Jean Prouve: La Masin Tropicale, The Tropical House. Paris: Editions du Centre Pompidou, 2009, page 108.



"The dispatch of the first Tropical House to Africa was Niamey-bound, transported as air freight" (image). Henry, Patrice. Jean Prouve: La Masin Tropicale, The Tropical House. Paris: Editions du Centre Pompidou, 2009, pages 94-5.



"Tropical house being delivered and unloaded from a cargo aircraft" (image). Vegesack, Alexander van. Jean Prouve: The Poetics of the Technical Object. Vitra Design Stiftung, 2005, page 210.


"Vertebrae of the ventilation system and the legs of the porticos" (image). Henry, Patrice. Jean Prouve: La Masin Tropicale, The Tropical House. Paris: Editions du Centre Pompidou, 2009, page 96.



La Maison Tropicale Technical Drawings











The Tropics

Jean Prouvé designed La Maison Tropicale with the Congo climate in mind. The Congo has a hot and humid climate, with little variation in temperature between the wet and dry seasons, and between day and night. Prouve specified every aspect of his design to suit these extreme conditions.



Satellite photo of the Congo rain forests. (Source)


The house is supported by fifteen stilts. This allows the house to be situated on most of the ground conditions present in the Congo, as well as take advantage of the higher air flow.


Stilts after refurbishment. (Source)





Stilts used in La Maison Tropicale were similar to those used in primitive huts in the area.


The windows, doors, and other openings also make the most of the wind. The windows are circular portholes consisting of a treated glass which protects from harmful UV rays. Certain portholes are operable, and are controlled by disks. However, most of the air movement comes from sliding door panels on the north and south sides. These doors, through their placements, limit the amount of sun that enters through their large openings while maximizing cross breezes. Additionally, surrounding the veranda is a set of louvers, which assist in controlling the sunlight while still allowing the much needed ventilation. Essentially, the house promotes free airflow.


Design of the roof was derived from indigenous techniques for shading.



Sliding door with porthole windows. (Source)




There are a few exceptions to this free ventilation aspect. Primarily, the washrooms were separated from the main interior spaces, with access only from the outside. This prevents the excessively moisture laden air from entering the already humid living space. The plan also maximizes on the outdoor living space with a two metre wide veranda surrounding the entire house. This is covered by a wide overhang which protects from the sun as well as rain, and prevents material decay. This overhang is part of a double roof system, which increases ventilation and allows for heat dissipation to the outside.



Jean Prouvé's ventilation system developed from indigenous techniques


The roof and walls are light coloured, to diffuse the glare of the sun and reflect the radiation. The walls also do not absorb moisture, and are resilient to fungus and mold growth. Many portions of the walls are sliding, which provides unobstructed air flow and releases any moisture back into the atmosphere. These walls are not for a thermal barrier, since the large roof overhang protects them, but are designed more for privacy and to reduce insect disturbances.




A view of both the interior and the surrounding veranda. (Source)


Since La Maison Tropicale was designed as a prototype for modular housing, the siting conditions and orientation are malleable. Its original placement was at the bottom of a short hill, overlooking the street. Two other residential buildings surrounded La Maison Tropicale, and the third side of the lot was forested. However, these conditions were not the main factors in designing for the climate. The shorter walls were designed to be on the east and west sides, to minimize the amount of sunlight hitting the building. The adjustable stilts allow for variations in the ground conditions, including swamps and hills. These stilts also lift the house high up into the breezier air, a technique already used by many natives to the Congo. Infact, many of the design principles that greatly assist in reducing the heat were very common in the Congo, but in a cruder style.


-Clara Walker






Information Citations:

Hamilton, William L. "From Africa to Queens Waterfront, A Modernist Gem For Sale to the Highest Bidder" (2007).
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/16/nyregion/16house.html (accessed January 5 2010).

King, Emily. "Grand Designs" (2007).
http://www.frieze.com/issue/article/grand_designs (accessed January 5 2010).

"Prouve House for Design Museum at Tate Modern" (2008).
www.tate.org.uk/about/pressoffice/pressreleases/2008/14056.htm (accessed January 5 2010).




Image Sources:

Huppatz, D.J. "
Maison Tropicale Sliding Doors" (image). Available from: Critical Cities
http://djhuppatz.blogspot.com/2007_05_01_archive.html (accessed on January 5 2010).

"
La Maison Tropical" (image). Available from: flickr.

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/202/515386615_236489cbef.jpg (accessed on January 12 2010).

"
La Maison Tropicale by Jean Prouve" (image). Available from: que-sited.
http://designknowledge.quesited.com/?m=200802 (accessed on January 5 2010).

National Geographic. "
Last Place on Earth" (image). Available from: The Congo.
http://rainforests.mongabay.com/congo/forestry.html (accessed on January 5 2010).

Colonial Reign

The French Congo was the original French colony. In 1879 and 1880, French explorer Pierre de Savorgnan de Brazza established control north of the Congo River. Consequently, France claimed the region as a colony in 1891.



France's African colonies. (Source)


French colonial rule included exploitation of raw materials such as ivory, rubber, palm oil, cotton and timber, as well as exploitation of the Congolese people through forced labour. Between 1892 ad 1896, the Congolese led many revolts against the French in reaction to French policy of maltreating the local population. However, the French enacted the Code de L'indigenat Act to further control their colony. It introduced forced labour and prohibited the airing of grievances by the local population. French rule was cruel and resulted in many deaths. Between 1921 and 1934, a railway was constructed between Brazzaville and Pointe-Noire, and it is estimated that between 15,000 and 20,000 died.



French General Charles de Gaulle. (Source)


During World War II, French General de Gaulle played a significant role with regards to the involvement of France's African colonies. In August of 1940, he led troops that secured various areas of Africa including Chad, Cameroon and Middle Congo. Consequently, in October of 1940, de Gaulle set up a Conseil de Defense de l'Empire of which he was the ruler.

Between 1944 and 1946, de Gaulle served as the President of the Provisional Government of the French Republic. However, his influence on the administration of the colonies continued after his resignation. In 1947, de Gaulle ordered housing to be put in place for the generals involved in the colonization of Congo. Jean Prouve was commissioned to design and manufacture prototypes of the Maison Tropicales to be shipped to Africa.

Prouvé worked in metals and had affiliation with Aluminum Francais (AF), an aluminum manufacturing company based in France. Prouve allied with AF because of its ties to the French government and to have access to markets. However, this alliance was not always mutually beneficial. The design and manufacture of the Maison Tropicale, as well as other prefabricated housing projects, was altered to appease AF requirements.

France was committed to the assimilation of its colonies into the French culture, and this assimilation extended out to assimilating architecture and building techniques. Public buildings and white neighbourhoods openly displayed modern architecture and convenience in order to contrast existing indigenous architecture. Prefabricated housing was to be a visual example for the superiority of urban life and the French culture. For the capital development of colonial Africa to succeed and benefit the French, it was essential that colonists and Africans no longer used local and free building materials. In fact, planning bylaws instituted by the French government required that all building components used in their African colonies be of European manufacture. Despite Prouvé's intentions of merely building a house for the masses that was both climate responsive and portable, once erected, the Maison Tropicale supported the political agenda of the French government.

In 1960, the Republic of Congo became an independent state. Despite this autonomy, the Republic of Congo has had many civil wars and is continually in political turmoil.

-Stephanie Koltun




Information Citations:

Cahoon, Ben. "Congo" (2000).
http://www.worldstatesmen.org/Congo-Kinshasa.html
(accessed Janury 7 2010).

Guiler, Derek. "Democratic Republic of the Congo" (2002).
http://www.essortment.com/all/democraticrepub_raob.htm
(accessed January 7 2010).

"History of the Congo" (2009). Available from: Friends of the Congo.
http://www.friendsofthecongo.org/historyofcongo/index.php
(accessed January 7 2010).

http://www.peace.ca/afcolonialismcongo.htm
(accessed January 7 2010).

http://njisworld.wordpress.com/mr-duells-articles/the-dark-continent-european-colonization-in-africa/
(accessed January 7 2010).


Image Sources:


"French Equatorial Africa" (image). Available from: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:French_Equatorial_Africa.PNG

(accessed January 2010).


"General Charles Andre Joseph Marie de Gaulle" (image). Available from: Maritime Quest.
http://www.maritimequest.com/warship_directory/france/aircraft_carriers/charles_de_gaulle_r91/fs_charles_de_gaulle_general_de_gaulle.htm
(accessed January 2010).

La Maison Tropicale

In 1947, housing was ordered to be put in place for the generals involved in the colonization of the Congo. Architect Jean Prouvé, who devoted his career to prefabricated designs, was commissioned to design and manufacture prototypes of what would later be called "La Maison Tropicale". Because France was very committed to the assimilation of its colonies into the French culture, the Maisons were to be built using only French materials and building techniques, which contrasted the existing indigenous architecture.

Prouvé designed three prototypes which were of prefabricated construction. The prototypes of were made and partially assembled in Maxeville, France then shipped to their destination. One house was shipped to Niamey, Niger and the other two were shipped to Brazzaville, Congo.

The two prototypes sent to Brazzaville were a house which linked to an office via a bridge. Both buildings were very similar in design with the only main exception being that the office was smaller than the house. Here, the prototypes were placed on stilts over a swamp so it could be seen from street level and have a maximum visual impact for the promotion of the company Aluminum Francais. The smaller prototype was used as a company office for Aluminum Francais. The larger prototype was the temporary home of Jacques Piaget, the company's commercial director at the time.

Prouvé designed the Maison Tropicale based on a 1m by 1m grid. The smaller office building is 10m by 14m, while the larger house building is 10m by 18m. The height of both buildings is 4.8 metres.
The prototype which was shipped to Naimey was used as the office of Paul Herbe, an architect-planner of the Niger colony. Herbe eventually wanted to expand this type of architecture to the schools and institutions in the Niger colony. The design of this prototype closely followed the others.


La Maison Tropicale buildings in Brazzaville, Congo. (Source)

After the decolonization of the Congo and Niger, the prototypes remained there until being recently rescued. Currently, two of the houses are in France and the third in England where they are being restored.


Reconstructed La Maison Tropicale on display in Queens, New York (Source)




Timeline
1884-85 - Congo colonized by France
1905 - First pre-fabricated house built in Liverpool, England 1924 - Jean Prouve opens atelier in Nancy, France
1939 - Jean Prouvé makes pre-fabricated barracks for the French army
1944 - Prefab housing becomes increasingly popular because of its ability to grant the homeless homes quickly after the war
1947 - Jean Prouvé moves his atelier to Maxeville, France
- General Charles de Gualle commissions Prouvé to design and ship houses to the African French colonies
1951 - Three prototypes of La Maison Tropicale are made in Maxeville and shipped to Niamey and Brazzaville
1960 - Congo gains independence
2000 - Eric Touchaleaume salvages all three prototypes of La Maison Tropicale from Africa and ships them to Paris for restoration


Smaller Brazzaville Prototype:
2004 - Eric Touchaleaume sells the smaller prototype from Brazzaville to Robert Rubin, an American collector. Robert restores the house.
2005 - La Maison Tropicale is displayed at Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut from February to May. Robert Rubin displayed La Maison Tropicale at the Hammer Museum, Los Angeles California from November to January 2006.
2006 - Rubin donates La Maison Tropicale to Le Centre Pompidou where it is to be displayed in an extension of the museum, Metz, located in Metz, France.


Larger Brazzaville Prototype:
2007 - La Maison Tropicale is shipped to Queens, New York for Christie's International Auction. For $4.97 million, it is bought by Andre Balazs, a founder of the New York Academy of Art.
2008 - La Maison Tropicale is exhibited outside Tate Modern in London, England
2010 - Andre Balazs plans on bringing his prototype back to a tropical environment, saying, "It will eventually end up as the centerpiece of some sort of environmentally sound resort [in Central America]".






Various locations of the three Maison Tropicale prototypes.

-Rachel Bruijns



Information Citations:

Azimi, Roxana. "Un Centre Pompidou-Metz Brumeux" (2008).
http://www.artclair.com/jda/archives/docs_article/59681/un-centre-pompidou-metz-brumeux.php
(accessed January 9 2010).

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9802E2DE163AF932A05752C0A96E9C8B63
(accessed January 10 2010).

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/16/nyregion/16house.html

(accessed January 10 2010).

http://djhuppatz.blogspot.com/2007/12/jean-prouvs-maison-tropicale-in-new.html

(accessed January 10 2010).

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601088&sid=asfx7w84nM&refer=muse

(accessed January 10 2010)

Rubin, Robert. "Jean Prouve: Tropical House" (2005).
http://hammer.ucla.edu/exhibitions/detail/exhibition_id/105

(accessed January 10 2010).

http://www.yale.edu/opa/arc-ybc/v33.n18/story8.html

(accessed January 10 2010).

http://lamaisontropicale.com/www/

(accessed January 9 1010).


Image Sources:

"Jean Prouve's Two Brazzaville Houses" (image). Available from: Institut pour l'Histoire de l'Aluminium.
http://etd.lsu.edu/docs/available/etd-11112009-125538/unrestricted/odaythesis.pdf
(accessed January 12 2010).

Winchell, Richard. "Maison Tropicale" (image). Available from: flickr.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/richardwinchell/532593466/
(accessed on January 12 2010)

Blog Image Sources

"Fort Nakhl" (image). Available from: Wandelen in Oman.
http://www.cs.otago.ac.nz/staffpriv/hans/stories/Oman.html
(accessed January 12 2010).

"
Frankincense Tears" (image). Available from: Phil's Philosophy.
http://pangaiastore.com/blog/?p=161
(accessed January 14 2010).

"
Frankincense Tree" (image). Available from: Economic History of the World.
http://simun.info/ehlog/
(accessed January 14 2010).

"
French Equatorial Africa" (image). Available from: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:French_Equatorial_Africa.PNG
(accessed January 2010).

"
General Charles Andre Joseph Marie de Gaulle" (image). Available from: Maritime Quest.
http://www.maritimequest.com/warship_directory/france/aircraft_carriers/charles_de_gaulle_r91/fs_charles_de_gaulle_general_de_gaulle.htm
(accessed January 2010).

Gramanitsch, Thomas. "
Nakhl" (image). Available from: Tommi's Homepage.
http://wolke7.birringer.at/~thomasg/Oman/forts.html
(accessed January 14 2010).

Hoang, Kim-Can. "
Desert Caravan" (image). Available from: hcphoto.
http://www.hcphoto.org/montharch05.htm
(accessed January 14 2010).

Huppatz, D.J. "
Maison Tropicale Sliding Doors" (image). Available from: Critical Cities.
http://djhuppatz.blogspot.com/2007_05_01_archive.html
(accessed January 5 2010).

"
Jean Prouve's Two Brazzaville Houses" (image). Available from:Institut pour l'Histoire de l'Aluminium.
http://etd.lsu.edu/docs/available/etd-11112009-125538/unrestricted/odaythesis.pdf
(accessed January 12 2010).

Kijal. "
Path of Darkness" (image). Available from: flickr.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/kijal/131160960/in/photostream/
(accessed January 10 2010).

Kijal. "
Protection" (image). Available from: flickr.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/kijal/130557871/in/photostream/
(accessed January 10 2010).

Kijal. "
Welcome to the Majlis Room" (image). Available from: flickr.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/kijal/131160955/in/photostream/
(accessed January 10 2010).

"
La Maison Tropical" (image). Available from: flickr.
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/202/515386615_236489cbef.jpg
(accessed January 12 2010).

"
La Maison Tropicale by Jean Prouve" (image). Available from: que-sited.
http://designknowledge.quesited.com/?m=200802
(accessed January 5 2010).
MacGregor, Malcom. "
The Fort at Nakhl" (image). Available from: fotobank.
http://fotobank.ru/image/JW01-2856.html
(accessed January 10 2010).

Micheal. "
Oman Desert 3" (image). Available from: pbase.
http://www.pbase.com/taketwo/image/40423213
(accessed January 10 2010).

"
Nakhl" (image). Available from: Oman, smells good to me.
http://www.igougo.com/journal-j38979-Oman-Oman_Smells_Good_to_Me.html
(accessed January 13 2010).

"
Nakhl" (image).
http://wolke7.birringer.at/~thomasg/Oman/forts.html
(accessed January 12 2010).

"
Nakhl Fort" (image). Available from: Wikimedia.
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Nakhl_Fort_04.jpg
(accessed January 12 2010).

National Geographic. "
Last Place on Earth" (image). Available from:The Congo.
http://rainforests.mongabay.com/congo/forestry.html
(accessed January 5 2010).

Nichols, Michael. "
Congo River Rainforest" (image). Available from: Travel & Cultures.
http://travel.nationalgeographic.com/places/photos/photo_congo_congo.html
(accessed January 12 2010).


"
Oase Nakhl" (image). Available from: Frauschroeder.
http://www.frauschroeder.com/OMAN1.HTM
(accessed January 12 2010).

"
Oman Desert" (image). Available from: lerochers.com.
http://www.lerochers.com/carnet-voyage/oman.htm
(accessed January 13 2010).

"
Outer walls of Nakhl" (image).
http://www.7is7.com/otto/travel/photos/20051019/oman_castle.html
(accessed January 12 2010).

"
Prouve" (image). Available from: A Few Items of Interest
http://www.maritimequest.com/warship_directory/france/aircraft_carriers/charles_de_gaulle_r91/fs_charles_de_gaulle_general_de_gaulle.htm
(accessed January 5 2010).

Rain, Andy. "
La Maison Tropicale ouside Tate Modern" (image). Available from: Art & Design Blog.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/artblog/2008/feb/07/lamaisontropicaleisonehot
(accessed January 13 2010).

Winchell, Richard. "
Maison Tropicale" (image). Available from: flickr.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/richardwinchell/532593466/
(accessed January 12 2010).


Vink, John. "
Panorama View of Nakhl Countryside" (image).
http://www.edwebproject.org/oman-dubai/nakhal.html
(accessed January 12 2010).


Images sourced by: Rachel Bruijns.